A1
No material category excluded
up 5 · held 12 · down 0
defeated 10 → 8 · passing 1 → 5
A2
A single reconcilable footprint
up 7 · held 8 · down 2
defeated 2 → 0 · passing 6 → 10
A3
Method, boundary and version transparency
up 5 · held 11 · down 1
defeated 8 → 8 · passing 0 → 4
A4
Granularity and assurance sufficient to lift
up 5 · held 9 · down 3
defeated 2 → 2 · passing 9 → 11
I1
Physical risk relevant and transparent
up 7 · held 9 · down 1
defeated 1 → 1 · passing 4 → 10
I2
Transition risk: derivable target headroom
up 1 · held 15 · down 1
defeated 6 → 7 · passing 1 → 2
I3
Targets met by real reduction, progress stated honestlyClaim criterion
up 5 · held 12 · down 0
defeated 15 → 10 · passing 0 → 0
I4
Portfolio and financed-emissions completeness
up 2 · held 15 · down 0
defeated 3 → 2 · passing 12 → 13
I5
Flow-through and look-through exposure
up 2 · held 14 · down 1
defeated 5 → 5 · passing 2 → 3
I6
Reconstructable by a sophisticated reader
up 1 · held 15 · down 1
defeated 1 → 2 · passing 5 → 6
R1
Headline matches evidence without cross-document work
up 6 · held 10 · down 1
defeated 11 → 7 · passing 0 → 2
R2
Targets cover the material sources; achievement honestClaim criterion
up 0 · held 17 · down 0
defeated 13 → 13 · passing 0 → 0
R3
Material risks legible
up 4 · held 13 · down 0
defeated 0 → 0 · passing 8 → 12
R4
Caveats findable and fairly presented
up 3 · held 13 · down 1
defeated 5 → 4 · passing 1 → 2
P1
Claims literally true within their implied boundary
up 4 · held 12 · down 1
defeated 10 → 6 · passing 2 → 4
P2
No misleading composite impressionClaim criterion
up 3 · held 14 · down 0
defeated 16 → 13 · passing 0 → 0
P3
Genuine climate action evidenced
up 3 · held 14 · down 0
defeated 0 → 0 · passing 9 → 12
G1
Standards compliance and readiness
up 5 · held 11 · down 1
defeated 0 → 1 · passing 4 → 9
G2
Cross-source and audience consistencyClaim criterion
up 4 · held 13 · down 0
defeated 16 → 12 · passing 0 → 0